Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by jabl 923 days ago
> I've seen estimates of $1000 in reduced cost due to reduced copper wiring

What about aluminum wiring? Lighter, cheaper, though bulkier than equivalent copper. Aluminum wiring got a bad rep back in the day, but it seems with current electrical aluminum standards it supposedly works pretty well.

2 comments

Aluminum is hell to terminate. It basically requires ultrasonic welding; every trade-show has folks hawking various crimp terminals that're meant to break through the surface oxides during the crimp cycle, but not a single automaker has been swayed enough to use it on normal wiring.

The reliability concerns really add up with flexing fatigue, too. It's one thing to put aluminum wiring in a house where its only flex is due to thermal expansion, and it has a hard enough time coping with that it's still a special category in home insurance, to say nothing of a vehicle that's going to spend the next ten-plus years bouncing over the road.

Furthermore, you basically can't modify aluminum wiring. In-line splices and solders are virtually impossible. While that's irrelevant for manufacturing, it hits the aftermarket pretty hard, including dealer mods, and of course, dealer repairs. That can be worked around but it would require communication between branches who don't normally talk, and it just adds friction to any possible aluminum migration.

I've seen aluminum in a single very-heavy-gauge battery cable for a car that put the battery in the back, with ultrasonic-welded terminals on both ends, and that's it. Everything else in that car was copper.

In sotuations where it is about space you wouldn't choose aluminum. Also afaik most automotive wiring that is certified is copper. Going from copper to aluminum means you will have to put bigger crossections in. This is more weight and more space.