|
Having worked with Lua and Elisp extensively, they have very different pros/cons profiles. In my experience, Lua is great as a scripting language - tiny, speedy, and completely dynamic. For "programming in the large(r)," Lua is just a little better than early JavaScript (i.e., tragic). The purity of the design - tables, metatables, closures, coroutines, and that's it - necessitates reinvention of tens of wheels (either in Lua or in the host app) when your codebase grows and complexity increases. Elisp provides two orders of magnitude more "bells and whistles" than Lua out of the box. Additionally, while Lua's primitives are extremely powerful, they are all strictly run-time constructs. Elisp has macros, so many abstractions can be (and are) shifted to compile time. I use Awesome WM. It's essentially an "Emacs of Window Managers," and the codebase is very well written, with a small C core and everything else implemented in Lua. It's even very well documented. Yet, writing a nontrivial program (call it an "applet" or something) for Awesome is a nightmare compared to doing the same in Emacs. LuaJIT is an excellent runtime, and Lua is a great IR, but writing it by hand for anything that's not strictly scripting within a previously established framework is challenging. It's to the point where I'm using Haxe to produce Lua for my Awesome scripts. I know a few people who use Haxe to script NeoVim, too. Really, having to reinvent inheritance and method resolution order every time you start writing Lua in a new project gets old fast. I genuinely like Lua as a language - the same way I like Tcl, Scheme, and Io. They are all beautiful and powerful and perform very well in some scenarios. Elisp is ugly in comparison, but it's way more practical for medium-sized codebases. Being tied to Emacs is a considerable downside which limits its applicability, but focusing on language features alone, larger codebases are more practical to write in Elisp than in Lua. Plus, there's an escape hatch - Common Lisp or Clojure, pick your poison - for cases where Elisp actually doesn't cut it. There's no such easy way out for Lua. |
I think there are some Lisp/Clojure inspired languages developed for Neovim which are used in Lua.
https://github.com/Olical/conjure
https://github.com/Olical/aniseed
https://github.com/Olical/nfnl