Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by dotancohen 931 days ago
Wow, that map is very political. Israel is not mentioned by name, but the Palestinian Territories are.
4 comments

Telecom Egypt is the sponsor of the map
So writing Israel isn't Political? Your definition of political is obviously biased.
Would writing Germany be Political? Writing Ukraine? These nations exist and are functioning parts of international relations.
Well Germany isn't occupying lands illegally or commiting war crimes every minute.
1. Neither is Israel, despite how your news source is trying to manipulate you.

2. Those nations that do occupy lands illegally and commit war crimes are in fact listed, so that disproves any connection to your supposed reason and the real reason for eliminating the name of the state of Israel.

> 1. Neither is Israel, despite how your news source is trying to manipulate you.

It's's occupying lands illegally according to the international court.

https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/campaigns/2017/06/israel-o...

https://www.ohchr.org/en/press-releases/2022/10/commission-i...

> 2. Those nations that do occupy lands illegally and commit war crimes are in fact listed, so that disproves any connection to your supposed reason and the real reason for eliminating the name of the state of Israel.

This sounds eerily similar to people trying to justify the apartheid in south Africa, oh our allies don't say it's bad so it's fine!

The end of the Israeli occupational doesn't mean the deportation of Jews, Jews lived in Palestine in Peace with Muslims and christians for a long time, it's a holy land for all three religions.

There is no selection of labels for disputed territory that will make everyone happy. It's inherently political.
With the exception of the ambitions of fringe terrorist groups, the land that Israel has ruled since 1948 is not disputed territory.
Maybe to avoid politics, the name of the region was used.
That would have been an acceptable explanation in the 1950s or early 60s. But after 1964 one of the sides adopted the regional name as a national identifier, thus invalidating it as a neutral name.