[bdonlan]

There is a difference between those two situations. In the many-worlds-ish interpretation, the Earth _never_ goes to either 0 or 100%. Instead, once the moment of reckoning passes, observations of earth return _both_ 'destroyed' and 'non-destroyed' values, entangled together. When you observe this at Andromeda, your own waveform ends up containing "you, having observed Earth's destruction" and "you, having observed Earth not being destroyed" simultaneously. Note that this doesn't require FTL - the combined waveform from earth arrives after however many light-years it takes to get to Andromeda.

The key is, you can never observe that this quantum-mechanical weirdness happened to you, because your point of view only admits a single result at a time. In otherwords, "you" observe everything simultaneously, but each observation happens independently, so you can never think about two mutually exclusive results at the same time.