[6gvONxR4sf7o]

But his guesses match the consensus, so it doesn't add to the stuff he's criticizing.

[samrus]

It sounds like you prefer something that's more sensational simply because it's more sensational

[michael_nielsen]

Fair enough. I suppose the useful bit is that lots of ignorant people have gone nuts ("OMG this is AGI!") without any details. That's just hype. But, yes, to your point, there is also some substantive and interesting speculation from more knowledgeable people.