Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by wtallis 937 days ago
There's no "fool it into thinking it's displayport". What you're describing is having the Mac actually literally emit a DisplayPort signal, and a separate device converting that to an HDMI signal. The USB-C HDMI Alt mode standard was never implemented by any real products, and all USB-C to HDMI converters are active adapters that consume DisplayPort signals and emit HDMI signals. Not all of those support HDMI 2.1, which introduced a drastically different signalling mode for HDMI in order to support much higher data rates (and also added display stream compression, further increasing the maximum resolution and refresh rate capabilities).
1 comments
thejazzman 936 days ago
You're missing the point -- you have to use custom firmware on those adapters or Apple still only puts out 4k60

I went deep on this last night shopping for a cable

link
wtallis 936 days ago
The custom firmware isn't actually all that interesting of a point, because slightly broken display behavior is extremely common if you look closely at anything other than normal everyday TV resolutions and refresh rates.

USB-C/DP to HDMI adapters often need to do some amount of rewriting EDID information because they need to be transparent to the host computer and the display, so it's the adapter that's responsible for ensuring that modes that cannot be handled on both sides of the adapter are not advertised to the PC. When you layer that complexity on top of the existing minefield of ill-conceived EDID tables widespread in monitors, on top of the limitations of macOS (limited special-case EDID handling, little to no manual overrides/custom mode settings), it would be more surprising if there weren't some common use cases that theoretically ought to work but are simply broken. Applying the necessary EDID patch via adapter firmware is simply the easiest option where macOS is involved.

Even on Windows with a DP cable directly from GPU to display it's not all that rare to need a software override for EDID in order to use modes that ought to work out of the box (eg. I have a recent Dell monitor that cannot simultaneously do HDR and variable refresh rate out of the box).

link