[kubik369]

Why do you think that Zelda should have stayed 2D? Some Zelda games, such as OoT, Majora's Mask and BotW to name a few, are considered to be some of the very best games ever made.

[asylteltine]

I could never get into those. All the 3d Zelda games are not Zelda they are something else. Not saying they are bad, but they aren’t really Zelda.

[lotsoweiners]

I’ve played every Zelda game and I’d rather replay A Link to the Past than any of ones you mentioned.

[Shared404]

I've played every 3d zelda (most of them more than a decade after release and several playthroughs), and bounce off the 2d games every time I try.

Both are good, but I don't think either is capital B Better.

[lotsoweiners]

To some extent it probably depends on where you started with the games. I was about 6 or 7 when the original The Legend of Zelda came out. I had well over a decade of playing Zelda games before OOT came out, I was in college at the time. If I had been a kid when OOT came out then that, or one of the other 3D games, might have been my favorite.