Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by ibz 947 days ago
This is indeed one of the issues I still didn't fully wrap my head around!

Currently clients just use the same bunch of relays as defaults, and let you (maybe) customize the relays you want to connect to.

I think this is sub-optimal for another reason, besides the one you mentioned (discoverability?): you don't necessarily control where your data is stored, and these relays might disappear without notice. It is a great way to broadcast status updates, but not great for having an archive of your own data, that you can trust.

I assume this will change eventually, with paid relays, which will have the incentive to keep your data around, OR personal relays - which is what I am building as part of my CMS - basically I want all my data to have one "canonical" location (my domain) and be hosted on my VPS, which also serves my data as a web page with RSS... this helps me wrap my head around where my data is stored, and know that I always have a copy of it... but doesn't solve the discoverability issue, I guess, which ... IDK, it seems to be solved using just a "shotgun" approach: mostly publishing to well know relays.

2 comments

See my comment here explaining how Nostr aims to solve this: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38346741
I would love to read/hear more about this NOSTR based CMS. Do you have a website or nostr channel I can follow to hear about a alpha/beta launch date?
Just a GitHub. [1]

It's very early days still, but I use it myself.

The marketplace [2] is much more advanced! You can already use it to buy and sell stuff over Nostr!

[1] https://github.com/servuscms/servus [2] https://github.com/PlebeianTech/plebeian-market