Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by spigottoday 942 days ago
An llm is a database modelled on the concept of a neural (the tissue in our heads) net (because our neural tissue appears to be highly interconected like a net). An llm is a very interesting and complex tool that the creators and many users anthropomorphize this shit out of. Llm's are a spherical cow, a statistical model of a very poorly understood organ and difficult to define process; intelligence. Do we "prompt" our sql databases? When our querry results are incorrect is the database hallucinating? As amazing and usefull as these new ai tools are they are it seems to me they are no more intelligent or conscious than a hammer or guitar or the computer your using right now. I thinks a usefull perspective to apply to ai is competence. To clarify this I will compare an llm to a flea. A flea has a neural network that outperforms any hardware used for ai. Fleas eat, mate, avoid preditors and probably exibite a great deal of complex behavior that we are not aware of. Fleas are highly intelligent competent actors opperationg in a complex environment. Llms are not actors any more than a hammer or a sql database is and only an actor can be competent. I will agree that in most cases llms have more utillity than fleas. Consciousness seems alot more slippery than intelligence which is hard enough by itself.