Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by skyyler 946 days ago
https://www.resources.org/common-resources/how-much-do-regul...

Interestingly, the large trucks and SUVs seem to be partially the result of fuel efficiency regulations.

4 comments

That wasn't new in 2012, I can remember it being discussed back in 2006 and that SUV graph continues back in time to around 1985-1990 or so.

Doubt they manage to close the loophole, it is too profitable.

I also wonder if the increase in Americans' weight over the years has played a role. Big trucks and SUVs are often more comfortable for larger people.
No, the reaction by truck manufactures (Ford, etc.) was to switch from a "passenger car" chassis, which is regulated under CAFE, to a "light truck" chassis, which isn't. Remember that the PT Cruiser was classified as a "light truck". I think we can all agree that in no way shape or form would the average person believe the PT Cruiser was a truck.

https://www.thedrive.com/news/small-cars-are-getting-huge-ar...

https://www.thetruthaboutcars.com/2012/10/how-cafe-killed-co...

> Under CAFE, vehicles can be labeled “passenger cars” or “light trucks”, with the latter category required to meet less stringent standards for fuel economy and CO2 emissions. A decade ago, the Chrysler PT Cruiser was the most egregious example of this.

> Big trucks and SUVs are often more comfortable for larger people.

This plays some part in it. I am fairly tall, and have longer legs, and there are sedans that I simply cannot fit into because they do not have enough room for my legs. Nevermind a coupe of any kind.

I do have a pet theory that part of the problem with bad drivers, especially inattentive drivers is that they're far too comfortable in their cars. They sit in a big cushy drivers seat with gods-knows-how-many adjustment zones, in-seat heating, cooling..massage even. Driving becomes a time to relax rather than a time to concentrate.

They're more comfortable full stop. And you feel safer, even if that is (maybe) an illusion.

I prefer sedans, but longer distance traveling is very nice in my wife's mid-sized SUV.

I'm 6'2" and weigh 250lbs. My Honda Civic has no problem whatsoever accommodating my size.
Great example of unintended consequences
The result of loopholes in regulations.