Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by anonymouskimmer 950 days ago
> When is it ever advantageous to reject truths?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-fulfilling_prophecy

I.e. It becomes problematic when it involves human behavior at a stereotypical level. This isn't to say that stereotypes don't sometimes exist for preexisting (non-self-fulfilling) reasons, but even some people prone to sociopathy can leave good lives if properly treated.

1 comments

Treating sociopaths is not the same as lying about sociopaths or sociopathy because you think doing so will prevent sociopathy.
Sure. The key is whether a statement is a genuine truth, or a policy based on a genuine truth plus various moral priors. Moral priors aren't genuine truths, they're predilections or rules of thumb.

And even baldly stating a genuine truth enough times will have effects outside of its truthfulness. People respond to truths, they don't just hear them.

So what if people respond to truths? Is there something wrong with that?