Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by COGlory 951 days ago
Music consumption has basically never been in a better place. What Spotify pays artists, and how many employees at Bandcamp get laid off are minor, in the big picture.

My music consumption goes something like this:

1) Queue up a known band on Spotify. See what else similar to them Spotify puts into a playlist

2) Listen to the new music, decide what I like or don't like

3) Head over to Bandcamp or Discogs with the stuff I really like. Buy it in vinyl and DRM-free digital. Put it in my Subsonic server.

4) If it's not available, head to P2P app of choice - they always have it.

Yes, Bandcamp and Spotify might be ephemeral, but Spotify did wonders for discoverability - there are a lot of albums from tiny tiny bands I'd never have bought if it weren't for Spotify, and Bandcamp helped re-establish the market for physical, DRM-free media.

Music has never been in a better place. I finally get to have my cake and eat it too. What people are complaining about (Spotify not paying enough to smaller artists) is conveniently ignoring that I'd have never even heard of those artists 25 years ago, because they couldn't have paid for distribution. Spotify didn't reduce what artists make, they redisributed what I spend across way more, but smaller, bands.

3 comments

> Music has never been in a better place.

I have to agree. I’m 66 years old. When I was in my late teens, I was intensely into music and doing my best to explore and learn about a variety of genres.

It was hard. I couldn’t afford to buy many albums, the music played on the radio was limited, and the only way to hear obscure music that I had read about was to go to a large public or university library and hope that they might have the records in their collection.

Now I can listen to nearly any music I want to with just a few clicks. There are also many great streaming channels for discovering music I didn’t know about—I particularly like BBC Sounds, especially Radio 3. My 19-year-old self never could have dreamt of such riches.

I’m the same age, and totally agree. Sometime in the late 80s or early 90s I decided to figure out what electronic dance music was all about. This was early house and techno times. It was essentially impossible. There was no scene in my city. Now I feel like there’s an embarrassment of riches, more than I could ever listen to.
You may like this John Peel archive to (re)discover music:

https://davestrickson.blogspot.com/2020/05/john-peel-session...

Music has never been in a better place? Do you work for Spotify?

Musicians are largely struggling while a few giant corps take all the money. Thats not a good place at all.

I think you are conflating “music” with “music consumers”

It's always been like that, just way worse because there were 100x fewer bands and artists even 30 years ago.

>I think you are conflating “music” with “music consumers”

I think you somehow missed the very first sentence of my comment:

>Music consumption has basically never been in a better place.

> Musicians are largely struggling while a few giant corps take all the money.

But that’s the way it has always been.

No, you are conflating "music" with "musicians", it's the same in most creative fields, we have more and better, by an order of magnitude, than we have ever had.
'head to P2P app of choice' - any recommendations?
Soulseek is still around