Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by xtian 956 days ago
How are western companies blocked from accessing China’s domestic market? Because they are obligated to follow local laws? That’s like saying GDPR blocks American companies from operating in Europe.
3 comments

Obviously it may or may not be like that, depending on the specific laws, parties involved, and possible consequences
This isn’t a new subject. For instance, both Google and Facebook are not allowed in China despite their past attempts to comply with mercurial and vague CCP laws.

https://www.businessinsider.com/major-us-tech-companies-bloc...

I’m sure there are more US companies and industries that are not allowed to compete in China’s domestic market.

The GDPR is protectionist legislation for EU companies, but it doesn’t prevent US companies from doing business in the EU. It’s a terrible comparison to the CCP’s outright ban on many US companies.

So how does Microsoft manage it? Bing and other Microsoft properties are accessible in China.
Most likely because China relies on Windows? I don’t know and it’s a moot point.

All I know is that there has been a large swath of US and other Western companies that are barred from doing business in China. That’s a fact. As to why, it’s likely protectionism for local mainland companies who wouldn’t have been able to compete.

The "why" is because Microsoft and Apple follow Chinese laws.

Just like Tesla, Ford, and GM follow Chinese laws and can operate in China.

The other companies refused to follow Chinese laws, so they aren't allowed to do business in China.

As I’ve already mentioned multiple times, other companies tried to comply with CCP laws but they were blocked out anyways.
What’s a specific example?
They cut a deal. Just like how apple partners with a chinese firm to store chinese users' data in china.
“Cut a deal” or maybe they followed local laws
"GDPR blocks American companies from operating in Europe."

Actually it does, because of extraterritoriality of US laws.