Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by s1artibartfast 956 days ago
Honest question:

I frequently hear people bring up transmission losses as a concern, and genuinely curious where this idea comes from? Was this taught in schools or part of some disinformation campaign?

2 comments

My understanding is that it is "simple" resistance heating of the transmission lines (P = I^2 R). Which is why high voltage lines are good ideas ( V = I R ) -- they lower the current.
Heating can be quite significant. I guess whether or not it’s economically significant depends on your cost of generation. There was a mega-outage which cut off Italy when overheated, sagging cables, struck the treetops in the middle of either another random outage or some scheduled maintenance. It’s been many years since I read the full report on the incident (which was excellent) but there was some great data in there about degrees of heating vs degree of sagging.