| Great points that show regional databases are not obviously simpler than one global database, especially from the application developer's perspective. > How do you deal with entities who are near the boundaries and whose current operational data therefore spans >1 shards? (Imagine somebody at near the geographic intersection of like, five shards looking for pizza in a 10 miles radius or w/e) Hitting 5 shards might not be that bad. I think you could divide the world into sufficiently large hexagonal tiles; you'd hit at most three shards then. Maybe each fixed-size tile is a logically separate database. Some would be much hotter than others, so you don't want to like back each by a fixed-size traditional DBMS or something; that'd be pretty wasteful. > Also the majority of entities they're tracking (users, drivers) do not have fixed locations. Yeah, you at least want a global namespace for users with consistent writes. The same email address belonging to different people in different regions is unacceptable. In theory the global data here could just be a rarely-updated breadcrumb pointing to which database holds the "real" data for that user. [1] So you can make the global database be small in terms of data size, rarely-written, mostly read in eventually consistent fashion, and not needed for geographically targeted queries. That could be worthwhile. YMMV. [1] iirc Spanner and Megastore have a feature called (something like) "global homing" that is somewhat similar to this. For a given entity, the bulk of the data is stored in some subset of the database's replicas, and bread crumbs indicate which. If you get a stale bread crumb, you follow the trail, so looking up bread crumbs with eventually consistent reads is fine. [edit to add a bit more context:] One major use case for this is Gmail. It has tons of regions in total, but replicating each user's data to more than 2 full replicas + 1 witness would be absurdly wasteful. [edit:] looks like CockroachDB has the concept of a per-row preferred region, which might also be vaguely similar. <https://www.cockroachlabs.com/docs/v23.1/table-localities#re...> I haven't used CockroachDB and only skimmed this doc section. |