Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by radium3d 969 days ago
I don't think it's the ads people need to be worried about. It's pages, groups and their "users" posts manipulating people. News flash: a majority aren't even real human users.
5 comments

Why not both?
Ads are less worrisome because you know they're an ad because they are marked with a icon usually. It's the fake posts that are tricking people into beliefs without them even realizing that it's propaganda/ads
I wonder if one day there will be a majority of bots liking AI-generated content, so it will be a closed loop.
Long after the last human logs off we still have to run it because it will be the primary economical engine of tech.
I the term bot is interesting, I think it cbelievean be expanded to any automata predictably responding in a certain fashion. Twitter "reply" accounts even if operated by humans but acting like bots should be considered bots. Posts that don't move the discussion along but just reaffirm in one direction or the other are just pure noise and useless. Discourse is broken or the human brain is, unsure which it is.
Source that dissects this?
I always doubt anyone who sees 'bots' everywhere they go, but I agree with them on the groups part. https://old.reddit.com/r/ShitMomGroupsSay/ regularly has some good examples.

Ironically, I've posted there a couple of times in a way that (barely) went against their own groupthink and got downvoted like crazy.

I wonder how much of these are powered by GPT.
There are some articles regarding it. https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2023/jun/05/google-an...

My personal theory is that we have been mingling with AI generated content long before Chat GPT was revealed to the public, at least in the last 10-15 years. And that Chat GPT was not the first on the block manipulating people with the technology. I just think this based on the fact that the NSA was spying on people long before whistle blowers revealed it, same has to go for AI manipulation by various government agencies and non government "bad actors". We may get confirmation of this within the next 10-15 years if someone blows a whistle.

None, another internet, drivel-fueled LARP.
> "users" posts manipulating people.

Are we talking about MSM here? Because those doing it are real human users, some of them quite famous.