Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by trekkie1024 969 days ago
Looks like the latest MBA is only 0.1 lbs less than the equivalent MBP at 3.4 lbs. Feels like they used to be lighter.
2 comments

How are you determining "equivalent"? I don't agree with your conclusion at all.

My M2 MBA is 2.7lbs. The 14" MBP starts at 3.4lbs. That is a very noticeable 26% increase.

0.44 inches thick versus 0.61 inches thick is also noticeable.

I have a 14" MBP for work, so I have plenty of first hand experience with both devices.

The screen sizes of the relevant laptops are as follows:

    MBA (13in): 13.6 inches
    MBP (14in): 14.2 inches (+0.6in vs 13in MBA)
    MBA (15in): 15.3 inches (+1.1in vs 14in MBP)
The 13-inch and 14-inch are significantly closer in size than the 14-inch and 15-inch.

To add an additional spec for clarity, by my math the relative screen areas are as follows:

    MBA (13in):  84.36 square inches
    MBP (14in):  91.63 square inches (+8.6% vs 13in MBA)
    MBA (15in): 106.24 square inches (+16%  vs 14in MBP)
Why would the "equivalent" be the 15-inch MBA? Even though I obviously believe the 13-inch MBA is a closer match (as the specs above clearly show), the 15-inch MBA does still manage to be thinner and (barely) lighter than the 14-inch MBP, even while offering a significantly larger screen, which is impressive to be sure.
The resolutions and brightness are also relevant:

    MBA (13in): 2560 by 1664 at 500 nits
    MBP (14in): 3024 by 1964 at 1000 nits
    MBA (15in): 2880 by 1864 at 500 nits
I also would compare the 14" MBP with the 15" MBA" closer weight, closer display. If price wasn't a factor, the 14" MBP wins for me.
They also used to feel a lot thinner, with the taper at the front edge.

I don't like my M2 MacBook Air nearly as much as the M1, in terms of the physical feel and dimensions.

I had four or five gens of MBA over the years and generally agree. The new form factor is just not the same. It is much more like a how I'd envision design on some modern "Macbook" proper.

But the Air brand has been so successful, I think they just called it that knowing it would help move units.

That said, I use MBA M2 for my main machine and its so powerful and has such a fantastic battery life it is still the best Mac I've had since 2015 MBA.

I use an MBA M2 15in 24GB as my main and I agree.

I really enjoy the wedge shape of the original MBA that was maintained until the 2020 MBA M1, they feel better to my wrists than the 13 in MBA M2.

The 15in MBA M2 however feels to me like a 2012 15in MBP (I had one of those as well). Except for the relative lack of ports which didn’t bother me too much so far.