Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by thaumasiotes 963 days ago
> "Moscow Mathematical Papyrus" from 1850 BC. This is referred to as a manuscript rather than a "text" though.

There's no difference. A manuscript is a written document. A text is a written document.

1 comments

I think paleographers think of the text as an abstract object and manuscripts as approximations of it. E.g. you might have a couple hundred manuscripts (and other things like printings, etc) of Aristotle’s Physics, but the text is what you get after you identify and try to correct scribal errors.
That is not the same word "text" as used in the headline. (Note that you weren't able to say "a text".)

Wiktionary's definition page is something of a train wreck, but if you already know what to look for, the information is there:

> text (countable and uncountable, plural texts)

( https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/text#English )

Of course one word cannot be "countable and uncountable". But your "text" is uncountable, and bisby's "text" is not.

whereas I think in common usage text is anything written and manuscript is a subset of document.

Although manuscript in pre-computer days generally meant something handwritten, nowadays I guess you can turn in a manuscript that was written on the computer so not exactly the same.

I think this is right, although I think the connotations of “text” are a bit more abstract in common usage than “manuscript”.