Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by psychoslave 974 days ago
Did you ever tested the Stroop effect in a language, and how it effects depending on the proficiency in that language?

Language is certainly not the sole factor of conscious interpretation of all phenomena, stimuli and mechanisms that induce it, but it definitely is a factor with measurable effects.

And probably this is a skill where individual feel like the largest degree of freedom — the topic of whether this feeling is a mental illusion or backed on hard-wired physics is a distinct point.

Trying to destroy credibility of whole class of people striking them with an anathema like "mysticism" implies forgetting a bit quickly that Descarte’s grand scheme of thought came to live thanks to three dreams, Newton was found of alchemy and Russel dedicated a whole essay specifically to "Mysticism and Logic".

> I assure you I see these colours the same as you do.

Maybe not if I’m colour blind, right?

Now, this is not to promote the extreme other side: I don’t believe in an "absolute relativism" that would allow culture to shape arbitrary anything anyway regardless of any fundamental conditions that enabled human beings to form.

But certainly there a whole set of shade between this two poles (and beyond the linear spectrum they induce).

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stroop_effect

https://www.cairn.info/qu-est-ce-que-rever--9782749256627-pa...

https://www.philomag.com/articles/le-reve-de-descartes

https://www.gutenberg.org/files/25447/25447-h/25447-h.htm