Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by tornato7 974 days ago
I was curious if GPT-4 Vision could explain it:

The paper presents a geometric problem centered on equilateral triangles. The key question is whether it's possible to use \( n^2 + 1 \) small equilateral triangles (each with side length of one unit) to cover a larger equilateral triangle that has a side length just slightly more than \( n \) (specifically, \( n + ε \), where \( ε \) is a small positive value).

The two figures provided illustrate possible arrangements of the smaller triangles within the larger one:

1. *Figure 1*: This demonstrates that \( n^2 + 2 \) small triangles can cover an equilateral triangle whose side is \( 1 + ε \). It's evident that the small triangles fit neatly inside the larger triangle.

2. *Figure 2*: This shows a different configuration where the large triangle has a side length of \( 1 - ε \). It seems to suggest that with just one fewer triangle (i.e., \( n^2 \)), the tiling is not possible for a triangle of side length \( 1 + ε \), but it may be for \( 1 - ε \).

The paper, although succinct, poses an intriguing tiling problem in geometry. The authors likely aim to stimulate thought and discussion on this particular geometric configuration and challenge readers to consider the conditions under which such tiling is feasible. Given the brevity, the paper might be a problem statement or a brief note, rather than a full research paper with exhaustive proofs.

1 comments

It couldn't.
Pretty damn close though! I haven't seen an explanation of what the second figure is trying to show so I'm not sure about that one. (And also their assertion that no further explanation is necessary is clearly bullshit.)
Its attempts at explaining both figures are totally wrong. Wrong side lengths, wrong assertion that the small triangles fit inside the large triangles, wrong relationship between the figures, complete misunderstanding of the second figure.

The second figure is actually showing another arrangement of n²+2 small unit equilateral triangles covering an equilateral triangle of side length n+ε.