Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by fsckboy 977 days ago
"if NSA is your threat model" sounds like something somebody from the 1980's would say. It's been a long time now that we've known they spy on everybody and that they share the data, and they Five Eyes the data they can't get. NSA is everybody's threat model and it has been for a long time. Intervening in electoral politics, getting private companies to do their bidding... where have you been?
1 comments

The turn this thread has taken has been interesting. A few comments ago, stcroixx wrote:

>Have you ever seen security done right anywhere? In my experience, it's always the bare minimum.

I think there's a lot of ground between doing the bare minimum for security and hardening your organization against the NSA. Every step towards greater security is a step I support, even if your organization isn't able to reach the "hardened against the NSA" level.

I'm happy for you if you want to harden yourself against the NSA, but I dislike black-and-white thinking. I care about harms to users which come from non-NSA threats too. Case in point: the original post about hackers selling 23andme data -- presumably to clients who are not the NSA, in some cases.

If every discussion of how to improve security gets derailed into a discussion of how evil the NSA is and how practically no one is secure against them, then organizations will continue to do security badly, and we'll see more breaches like this 23andme breach. Fatalism is a self-fulfilling prophecy. I see it every day here on HN.

When "your" military officers are selling state secrets out for $5k in bribes [0], you realize there's probably very little you can do to prevent bad actors in positions of trust from blowing up any security model anywhere. Your only choice is between minimizing your risk with hoping for the best, or rolling your own everything and not taking part in any modern anything and living and dying alone. And even then, there's still probably going to be a file on you somewhere.

[0] https://abcnews.go.com/US/2-us-navy-sailors-arrested-alleged...