Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by fullarr 970 days ago
YouTube makes money by spying on you and serving you ads

So yeah it's theft

4 comments

The fact that someone makes money spying on me doesn't make it illegal for me to take countermeasures.

If your business is taking pictures of people on the street and I decide to wear a baseball cap and sunglasses, you're just out of luck.

This is a weak argument because YouTube isn't a public street it's a private business

You aren't forced to use it, it is a choice

And this application (FreeTube) is for the sole purpose of circumventing their (YouTube) monetization for the sake of convenience

I don't have a dog in the fight and I'm certainly not a fan of YouTube or Google, but you can't argue it's somehow ok just because you dislike ads or lack of privacy on a "free" video streaming website

And YouTube as a private business can refuse to serve people using ad blockers or alternative clients. But that doesn't make it illegal to use an ad blocker as the parent post was implying.
And if advertising doesn't influence you at all, would it still be stealing? I'm just saving them the bandwidth.
I'm not sure that's how the law works.
I'm confused as to whether you're for it against the behaviour.

I'd say both of those things makes it ok to do whatever you can to avoid them - given that YouTube appears happy enough to serve ads for various obvious scams that wouldn't make it past television advertising standards bodies.