[mynegation]

Could it be because your “to-read” Goodreads shelf is private?

[bellamk]

oh yeah I think it's the same for the other person too -- theirs is set to only be visible to Goodreads users

[mparnisari]

that was it! i had to make my profile public (not my shelf)

[danielskogly]

That was it for me! Thank you :)