Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by WillPostForFood 978 days ago
"they believed Jesus from Nazareth was the Messias and the other jews did not believe jesus was the messiahs"

Isn't that definition in opposition?

1 comments

Not in my understanding: it is

group A believes in X

group B believes in Y

What the parent poster seemed to imply was

group A believes in not Y.

Or a more concrete example of today, many people today define themself by being anti green, anti progressive, anti woke, antifashist etc. but often struggle to define what they are standing for.

The theory would be that given A believes X and B believes Y, A is more likely to incorporate ~X and B is more likely to incorporate ~Y.

And because beliefs tend to be on a bit of a continuum, what starts with A believes Z <= 4 and B believes Z >=5 evolves to A believes Z <=1 and B believes Z >=9, and both believe anyone who believes 3<=Z<=7 is not part of their group.