Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by BizarroLand 980 days ago
Not in most laptops they don't.

https://forum.arduino.cc/t/is-a-flyback-diode-built-into-lap...

"You will find those fans are brushless DC fans, they are controlled by an inbuilt driver circuit and as such do not need a flyback diode."

1 comments

So you "disprove" my statement with some rando on the Arduino message board that has less than 20 posts in their lifetime?

What makes you think they're an authority?

Brushless motor still have fly back voltage that has to be clamped. You may not need to install a diode in the fan, but I can guarantee you that this "inbuilt driver circuit" has such a diode.

And if you read the linked thread a bit more you'd see where they test it and it does produce -100V at shutdown. If there wasn't a flyback diodes it'd be burning out ic's left and right

Why would I accept your word without any backup?

Its on you to provide evidence of your claim, not on me to disprove your unfounded claim.