Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by artiscode 988 days ago
Can someone smart in EE explain why the author wants to avoid using a microcontroller? Cost per unit isn't an issue for this type of project, it makes things easier, allows to employ more advanced logic like sensing the monitor type to decide what monitor ID to send to the computer, you can have LED's and so on. It already requires 5V power for the chip, what would be the downside apart from added complexity?
2 comments
bogantech 988 days ago
The part where he talks about avoiding a micro is in regards to detecting activity on the various sync signals to turn on LEDs which is really simple and easy to do without having to resort to a micro

The microcontroller can't really help deal with the dip-switch mess because it would have no way of sensing whether the monitor supports Composite sync/Sync-on-green etc

link
ianlevesque 988 days ago
Someone was able to output 1080p(ish) with an RP2040, so yeah, it'd be doable.

https://hackaday.com/2023/03/31/could-1080p-video-output-fro...

link
happycube 988 days ago
The monitor signal is analog which means you'ld need a three-channel ADC to get it captured. might be able to do it with 4 or 6 bits per channel on a single rp2040, but you're probably getting into small FPGA (ice40?) territory there.

Maybe an pi5 could handle all three channels in 8-bit, depending on how the RP1 actually works. I'm hoping that it can handle a 40msps 10-bit ADC - a Domesday Duplicator hat would be wonderful.

The other option would be to find a vga->hdmi convertor that likes the signal coming out from this board, then you could plug that into anything modern.

---

When I first saw this I thought it was about an actual 9" classic mac, which I guess would be useful but IMO those are really designed around the CRT too much to make a replacement 'fit' well.

link
bogantech 988 days ago
RGBtoHDMI will convert the classic mac video to HDMI https://tinkerdifferent.com/threads/my-little-guide-on-rgbto...

It is also useful for several other kinds of machines such as the Amiga

link
ianlevesque 988 days ago
My approach would just be to sample one channel, like green, with the ADC and generate the sync signal, avoiding digital processing of the video itself. Just pass it through with any necessary level shifting in analog.
link
happycube 988 days ago
That'd definitely work.
link
artiscode 988 days ago
Interesting read, albeit the comments seem to suggest it's clickbait and a thought exercise, rather than a PoC or working solution. I was thinking more about an MCU that supplements the LM1881, not replaces it.
link