Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by amatecha 994 days ago
Due to proximity, the interference from the charger is comparable to what the receiver was expecting from a normal signal (like an amateur radio repeater or fellow operator's station), which is why his radio broke squelch while scanning. Because the radio is relatively close to the charger, the RFI is picked up quite well.

Comparing to a broadcast FM station, the strength of the RFI as observed by any nearby radio will be trivial by comparison. Broadcast stations are some of the highest-power radio transmissions around us, typically thousands of kilowatts (for example the rock station near me transmits at an ERP of 51,000 watts[0]). You will hear this station clearly no matter what kind of nearby RFI is present, and the receiver's AGC will reduce RF gain to probably as low as it goes. By comparison, amateur radios typically operate in the range of 5-100 watts. Thus you might gather that comparing localized RFI to broadcast stations is not a meaningful comparison.

[0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CFOX-FM

1 comments

> Broadcast stations are some of the highest-power radio transmissions around us, typically thousands of kilowatts (for example the rock station near me transmits at an ERP of 51,000 watts[0]).

I don't think so.

Not "thousands of killowatts" transmitted. Your example is as you say, an ERP of 51kW.

But even ERP doesn't refer to the transmitter. An ERP of 51,000W is most likely a 5-10kW transmitter, with a gain factor of 5-10.

Back in the pirate radio days 100 and 250kw transmitters were common.

Back in the '30s a few AM stations ran at 500kw, and could be picked up on other continents.

AM? Definitely, but even that is 100, 250, 500. Not "thousands of kW".
Oh sorry, I doubled up my units of measurement there, yes, tens of kilowatts haha :) (unfortunately too late to be able to edit that comment)