Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by dpflug 987 days ago
I've worked with judges. I could give you a mapping of charges to local judges where I'd prefer the judgement of 12 random people off the street.

This isn't a normal job. We don't hire 6 to 23 people for a single job, and jurors aren't random. Yes, jury summons are sent randomly, but they'll have hundreds summoned and then jury selection starts. It's not unlike a job interview. If someone is on the jury who's going to be biased or unreasonable, that's a failure of their legal counsel.

1 comments

Trust me if I was a defendant I'd prefer a jury system too because I know that people can be skillfully manipulated.

But such a trial has nothing to do with justice. It relies on the dark arts of psychiatry.