Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by alephnerd 994 days ago
> The entire idea of free speech really rests on something as shaky as the sticks and stones principle!

The "Free Speech means I can say anything I want on any platform" stance is actually very new in the United States.

This only started after the counterculture in the late 1960s-70s, when libertarian individualism (yes, the hippies had a very socially libertarian stance) in the New Left and the New Right lead to the revocation of laws such as the Fairness Doctrine, the Comstock Act, etc.

Before the 1970s-80s, American Free Speech doctrine was much closer to what you see in Canada, the UK, or Germany today - you are free to criticize and protest against the US Govt, but that doesn't mean you are free from moderation or censorship on a private or public platform.

Jurisprudence in the 70s-80s changed that by essentially removing the need for moderation, and that's how we have the irresponsible form of free speech that we have in the US today.

I blame Boomers and Gen X.

1 comments

Violating speech laws you disagree with is literally protesting the government.
It's essentially the paradox of tolerance. The solution to that paradox is to ignore it. To quote Chidi Anagonye, this is why people hate moral philosophy professors.