Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Schultzy 5200 days ago
Care to cite your source?

EDIT: I'm sorry, but was my request for a source considered rude? I don't understand the knock. I would really like to see some data showing the consolidation of wealth, if it actually exists.

3 comments

Your phrasing reads with a sarcastic tone to me, intentional or not.

But I'd also love to see a source, the claim alone does not convince me.

I'm actually not even sure what the claim is, actually -- are we talking about the top 5%? The top 1%? And are we talking about distribution within the entire world or within some specific nations?

I believe at least when you get to talking about the single richest person compared to their nation of residence, the richest person for the past few decades has controlled a smaller percentage of the wealth than in the early to mid 1900s or late 1800s -- see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_wealthiest_historical_f... -- but beyond that I have no idea how the distribution has changed either worldwide within nations.

Here are the Gini coefficients for the US over time:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gini_coefficient#US_income_Gini...

The Gini coefficient is the standard measure of income inequality.

Income is not wealth, income inequality is not wealth concentration (though perhaps could lead there).
I was simply trying to be helpful and providing data in response to someone who wanted some on wealth distribution. I can't believe you thought providing a source to closely related data deserved a downvote.

Sure, wealth and income are not the same, but they must be pretty correlated. I have read that the Gini is higher for wealth that income, but I haven't seen data for American wealth Gini coefficients over time. If you have that data, then you could be constructive and provide it.