Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by palata 993 days ago
Sorry, did you follow the stories about the impact of Facebook on the 2016 election in the US and the following "gilets jaunes" in France?

Seems to me that we have real life examples that show that it is not enough to just "let it be".

1 comments

misinformation is a key part of how politics works. This was the case before facebook, will be the case after facebook. 'Shaping the cognitive environment' is what the powers that be do. Probably best not to empower them further
> This was the case before facebook, will be the case after facebook.

Would you say that it was exactly the same before Facebook than after Facebook? I see an important difference of scale.

Scale matters.

all political information is a form of disinformation. Look at the Murdoch empire, pretty much global scale misinformation for decades. Facebook relatively minor in comparison
> all political information is a form of disinformation.

Doesn't make it all equal.

I see a difference between tailored information seen only by you on your computer in a controlled fashion and generic posters at the bus stop.

For one, if you put an unethical poster at the bus stop, some people may see it and complain about it. Whereas social networks can manipulate people on a 1-to-1 basis.