Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by placesalt 998 days ago
Does anyone know any more about Boox & GPL compliance?

The wiki page effectively says they are in violation:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Onyx_Boox#GPL_Compliance

> As of 2022, Onyx International Inc. has declined[20] to release the source code with Linux kernel modifications licensed under the GNU General Public License version 2 in response to a written request by a user. The GPLv2 license states that if a modified version of a covered work (such as the Linux kernel) is released, the corresponding source code must also be released under GPLv2.[21]

3 comments

I'm a Boox device owner and can confirm they declined my request for the GPL source code.
Same.
It's not good. Also, if you want to download an android app on one of their devices, you need to do it via their own app store type thing; the "official" google store app doesn't work out of the box and needs some to workarounds to activate. It's a Chinese company, so that's that
We should let the EFF know. That’s their whole deal, I thought.
That would be the SFC (https://sfconservancy.org/) I believe. Although Onyx is a Chinese company so little can be done.
I'm not a lawyer, but wouldn't having customs block BOOX imports into the country be quite feasible?

Probably need to get the SFC or similar to ask a court to issue some kind of judgement about it.