Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by politelemon 1001 days ago
> However, as with watchtower, that’s another external dependency.

Docker compose is part of docker now, it's just another subcommand.

2 comments

While you're technically correct, docker compose uses yet another process supervisor (the docker daemon) while systemd is already capable of doing that. This is probably what the author meant by 'external dependency' - not the need to install compose separately. Quadlet delegates the supervision to systemd daemon, eliminating this duplication of supervisor functionality.

Kubelets in K8s also have similar duplication of supervisor functionality. Perhaps this is a good place to mention the Aurae runtime [1], which is designed to replace systemd, docker daemon, kubelet, etc on dedicated worker nodes. Sadly, its chief designer Kris Nova passed away recently in an accident. I wish the rest of the team the strength of carry her legacy forward.

[1] https://aurae.io/

It unfortunately looks like Aurae is unmaintained at the moment.
Not quite, docker-compose is shipped separately by Docker as docker-compose-plugin. The plugin can then be reached with the subcommand "docker compose".

However, I agree with your sentiment. It's basically a part of any modern Docker installation now. Calling it an external dependency "like watchtower" is not a fair comparison.