Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by 7e 991 days ago
Tesla can’t solve self driving, but it will produce a bot which can function in an environment which is a hundred times more open and chaotic than a road system? I don’t think so.
3 comments

Unlike self-driving they aren't charging people in advance for something they haven't done, so I think this is fine. Plenty of companies are researching humanoid robots. I don't see why Tesla can't too.

This one does look quite impressive even if it is sped up a bit (find me a robot hand manipulation video that isn't).

Honestly the stakes are a lot lower for a humanoid robot IMO. There's a lot of risk around releasing FSD cars on public roads as opposed to testing out robots in a factory / controlled environment.

I'm actually really excited about the current state of robotics, and wouldn't be surprised if it ends up being the most impactful outcome of the most recent AI developments over the next 10-15 years.

I know there's a lot of hate for Elon Musk / Tesla, but at the end of the day he's just the money guy for some really great researchers out there.

> he's just the money guy

This argument never makes sense as it's pure circular reasoning. He's had no money to invest in anything without taking from some of his companies (which is what happened to Twitter). You can't invest in Tesla with money from Tesla.

> risk around releasing FSD cars

This reads like they haven't already taken that risk with fatal consequences.

Not seeing how a robot, literally marketed as being powered by the FSD computer, could actually work unless the underlying FSD system actually works. Which it doesn't.

I'm not sure about their marketing claims, but the robot in this video doesn't have wheels and isn't going 80mph on an interstate. Maybe the cars and this robot are using similar sensors, but I doubt there's a ton of overlap between the underlying system and the directions it gives. AGI doesn't exist yet
Psshhh they're only a few GPUs short of training this bot to drive the car for you. Checkmate!