Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by justsomehnguy 998 days ago
> Most modern cars will happily start at -20°C and many will start at -30°C without any special additions

A couple years ago temps here went below -25° and there were a lot of cars which didn't go nowhere. Sure, some of them just had a battery too low from the usual urban minimal distance travel, but I heard enough rants from and about people who was forced to abandon their car and use the public transport or taxi. Diesels without an engine heater were among them.

> don't ask me how I know, you just need to know what you are doing

Ye, have an 'offline' (lol) charger for your car battery or have a 'kick-starter' kit. The thing is what the cars sold here are prepared for the winter conditions, yet many of them failed at a slightly lower temps - which again shows how a mere 5° difference can be way too much even for things what work otherwise just fine.
1 comments
vc8f6vVV 998 days ago
People just don't care about their vehicles, that's why. There are multiple examples of even diesels starting at -25°C without heating. All my cars have been gas and while starting them at -30°C required some magical actions (like turning on headlights briefly to warm the battery up or depressing the clutch if you have a manual transmission) they all started most of the time. No extra tools or devices were necessary.
link
AnonHP 997 days ago
> or depressing the clutch if you have a manual transmission

What exactly does depressing the clutch do as compared to not doing it and starting the vehicle in neutral? Is it to reduce the engine load further? Or something else?

link
vc8f6vVV 997 days ago
Standard gear box oil is 80W90, which at -30C (even at -20C) turns into a thick jelly. Even in neutral starter has to move gears in that jelly. So normally you don't want to release the clutch until engine is warm enough and stable, and even when you do release it (in neutral) you do it slowly, sometimes in multiple attempts to avoid engine stalling, like starting on a steep hill. I haven't tried automatic at those temperatures, but ATF is much less viscous, so it should be much easier on the starter at low RPM.
link