Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by quickthrower2 996 days ago
I am dim today. Is this Tao getting rejected for some interview for something?
6 comments

These go by different names at different schools, but a grad student has to pass an oral exam, roughly at the end of their coursework and beginning of their dissertation phase. Sometimes called "orals," "comprehensive exams," etc.

By tradition, they can ask you anything. But in practice, they're not out to kill you. I went to a second tier university, and it was generally believed that the questions at a top school tended to be harder. I have no recollection of mine.

At this time, you also typically present a proposal for your thesis project. Passage of these hurdles makes you a "candidate," i.e., a candidate for a PhD upon defense of your thesis.

> Sometimes called "orals," "comprehensive exams," etc.

— other names I have heard people use for these: prelims, quals, ...

"Prelim" also sometimes refers to an exam taken shortly after entering a PhD program to ensure you belong there.

One of the grad schools I attended had both a written "prelim" in year 1 and an oral "qual" in year 2/3. The other just had an oral "general" in year 2.

"viva" in India
Princeton PhD students take a general exam as one of the major milestones of their PhD candidacy.

https://gradschool.princeton.edu/academics/degrees-requireme...

It's his "general exam" to start his PhD at Princeton

It's just faculty ensuring he has enough general knowledge of mathematics

At this point in time he would've been a teenager

I think when it is written "They passed me" it meant that he passed the exam.
it is an oral exam as part of a phd. this was years ago (1996?), so interesting as a retrospective.
He's one of the preeminent living mathematicians.
Fields Medal winner in 2006.

(And, as listed on his wikipedia page, 27 other awards, medals, and prizes.)

I knew that, I was wondering if this was Tao rejecting someone or being rejected himself!