| > At first glance, this might seem like a step back — perhaps even un-Svelte-like. Isn't it better if let count is reactive by default Actually, it was Svelte who coined the term and sold us on the idea of reactivity by default. I don’t think anybody asked for “Reactivity by default”. Svelte advanced this idea, and it helped the framework gain traction. It was easy to get started, and gave Svelte this sense of better ergonomics than other frameworks. I was always skeptical about the performance claims, amortized, and the real selling point of Svelte was ergonomics and the dev experience. The problem with the Node.js ecosystem is the devs are borderline marketing and sales type. They’ll justify, rationalize and make things sound good after the fact. Previously, Svelte was persuading us that Svelte was better than the rest because of reactivity by default. Now they did a literal 180. It’s probably in the right direction, and maybe how things should have been. A related symptom of the Node.js ecosystem is reinventing and rediscovering the wheel. The problem here is a lost of trust. Anything else which Svelte purports it’s got figured out or is more enlightened about should be taken with a grain of salt. So it seems those boring FANG engineers with React has it right all along. They had experiencing building sufficiently complex apps where verbose but explicit code was necessary. > Because the compiler can 'see' where count is referenced, the generated code is highly efficient Yeah, I don’t believe such claims anymore. Sure, in cherry picked and constrained settings, the performance benchmarks might seem good. As much as I hate to admit, I will reach for the production ready and battle tested React, as boring as it is. |
In Svelte 3, you had to opt in to running code on updates, using things like the `$:` label. It was designed to be conservative about updating components, unlike virtual DOM solutions that like to update everything unless you opt _out_.
I too am very sceptical of benchmarks — they can certainly obscure more than they reveal at times. But you don't have to take my word for it, or the benchmark results showing that Svelte 5 is faster than every other framework in existence (https://twitter.com/Rich_Harris/status/1688581184018583558) — you just need to understand the different mechanisms in play.