Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by psd1 996 days ago
Yeah bollocks. Guy Fawkes was attempting to reinstate a monarchy that the people roundly, and almost universally, despised.

The Jacobins were, exclusively, Catholic landed gentry.

Lopping off Chuckie's head set the stage for Britain's golden age, which goes to show: Tories have always been stupid as well as evil.

1 comments

The Tories didn’t exist until probably 50 years after Guy Fawkes was killed and when they did come to be they were quite anti-Catholic.
The late 17th was an exciting time in England, and far more complex than I could describe, no matter how long my comment.

The Tory party was not formed in a single day, not was every Tory born on a single day. There was continuity of actors and motivations.

It would have been politically inadvisable for an English nobleman in the period to be openly Catholic; nonetheless, many of them were, and this was certainly a factor in their favour of James, whose Catholicism was an open secret.

Remember that many of these tories spent a long time in exile, primarily France, a vigorously Catholic country.

Remember also that Catholicism was the state religion in Britain until disestablishment, a scant hundred years prior. Not all of the nobility converted - Mary found plenty of supporters.

I don't have the scholastic chops to back up this idea, but it seems fair to say that crypto-Catholic noble families would have been biding their time, nursing their resentments, and waiting for a chance to restore Catholicism to England. That was surely a factor in their support of James, who was clearly not a desirable king on his own merits - being raddled with syphilis and detested by the commoners.