Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by morkalork 1004 days ago
Seems like they should measure proportions using seconds streamed vs units streamed?
2 comments

They both seem primitive. If a user paid $10/month for a subscription, each month they should divvy that $10 to the proportional minutes listened of each artist for that month. That’s paying out to the people that are keeping that person subscribed. Minus Spotify’s cut of course
I'm sure that's where most people think their subscription money goes but the industry made sure it's not.
That’s kind of how SoundCloud does it (they call it user-centric payment model), it has the added benefit of curtailing fraud.
White noise and other background sounds cause issues here.
So Universal Music Group is depending on its competitor, Warner Music Group (owned by Access Industries which also owns Deezer)?

Interesting. I thought Universal/Warner/Sony were propping up Spotify as leverage for when they need to negotiate with Apple/Google/Amazon.

Those are already an issue that Spotify has.

https://www.engadget.com/spotify-almost-removed-white-noise-....

How so, maybe that just means those white noise tracks bring the most value.
Right? As a user, if I listen to 2 hours of content split equally between sources A and B, it seems fair that they each get half of my subscription fee (less Spotify's cut). Regardless of if A views B's content as "less worthy". On the other hand I wouldn't sign up for a monthly white noise service and if A went on strike and didn't renew license agreements, that's what Spotify would become. Record labels do have leverage over white noise which is a commodity (right? y'all aren't beholden to certain streams are you??)
I actually do have certain episodes/streams saved that are my go-tos.

Navigating "rain sounds" has become a lot more difficult lately specifically due to record labels complaining, particularly if you want one continuous 8hr stream. Instead all I can find now are playlists with a bunch of things I don't want. If I didn't have my favorites already saved I wouldn't be able to find them at all now.