Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by WirelessGigabit 1004 days ago
A basic Costco membership is $60. Their chicken is $5 + tax. Same chicken at Safeway is $8.99 + tax.

So if you eat >15 chickens per year Costco is cheaper.

And even that is incorrect. Costco's chicken is 32oz, the Safeway one 28. Forgetting about taxes, Costco's is $0.15625 / oz, Safeway is $0.3210714285714286 / oz.

So now we have 2 equations, and we need to find the intersection:

* y = 60 + x * 0.15625

* y = 0.3210714285714286 * x

They cross at 11.37594799566631 chickens.

But larger chickens have larger bones, so let's keep it at 15. I definitely eat more than 15 chickens per year.

Then there's the issue of cost in general, while the house-brands of Safeway / Frys / Kroger / ... are cheaper, they are much more likely to have stuff added to it to make it 'bulkier'. A good example is Cottage Cheese from Walmart. They add a thickener to the liquid which allows them to sell you the same amount for less, but you actually get less cheese and more filler.

1 comments

Walmart chicken is the same price as Costco and you don’t need a membership

I don’t know if the cottage thing is true or not, but even if it is, it doesn’t make difference for the customer if their goal is to save money

The problem with saving money is that they're replacing nutritious stuff with filler. So cheaper per oz, but you get a worse product.