Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by WalterBright 1020 days ago
Maybe an easier job would be to cool Venus by blocking sunlight from reaching it. Then, terraform it.
5 comments

An easier job would be maintaing the habitability of the near-perfect planet we already have x) but it seems we can't even to that! Seems silly when SV tech bros say terraforming other planets will be what "saves humanity" or some such vs.
What it gives us is a backup plan for humanity. There are many reasons the Earth could become uninhabitable, hardly all of them caused by man. For example, an asteroid hit.
temporal proximity to now, closest to furthest

0. climate change has already entered an irreversible spiral

1. decades from now, the irreversible spiral having deepened and accelerated, civilization as we know it has been destroyed, leaving no authorities to do anything about climate change

2. decades to centuries from now, climate change makes earth mostly uninhabitable

3. hundreds or thousands of years in the future, if they weren't all dead, humans perhaps would have been able to maintain a self-sustaining colony of all for humanity another planet

there's not a realistic path for humanity to survive an earth-destroying asteroid, and there never will be

And then you get a world bathed in eternal darkness until you control it's greenhouse gas atmosphere?

I think it would be easier to just limit greenhouse gas emissions on earth.

Your point works pretty well considering that Venus has a a dense atmosphere unlike Mars.

Just need to reduce the solar incidence, not eliminate it.

The same technology could be used to reduce gw on the earth:

1. an orbiting sunshade

2. putting something in the atmosphere that makes it more reflective, like sulfur dioxide

I wonder how big a sunshade would need to be to reduce temps by, say, one degree. A specific location could be shaded by putting the shade in geosynchronous orbit. To finance the sunshade, put a Starbucks or Coca-Cola logo on it.

The kind of sunshades that are reasonably being proposed are not large enough to see from the earth without a very powerful telescope.

A single giant megaproject sunshade is not feasible. But it is possible to make many smaller ones, each diminishing insolation by just a few fractions of a percent.

Or a giant “Welcome to Disney’s World.”
Since so many believe aliens are here already we might as well start advertising to them.
It certainly would. However, these are centuries long plans. A path along which the local issues will be solved.
the intellectual attraction lies exactly in terraforming other planets besides earth. Dreaming big.

> I think it would be easier to just limit greenhouse gas emissions on earth.

Of course it would, but that's besides the point

There’s a great video on terraforming Venus: https://youtu.be/G-WO-z-QuWI?si=7D-mamEMlkHgNkgS
"To speed things up, CO2 would be strategically released to supply the plants and cyanobacteria."

Somehow I doubt our ability to do this strategically...

But me big man. Me move mars.