Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by samstave 1010 days ago
Can it be taught "contextual matrices" where by it builds a new layer of construct but preserves the other, then cross learns between parameters or something (sorry for my poor lexicon, I'm wet-learning :-)

But imagine all LLMs in a macro view like a sponge entity
1 comments
tinco 1010 days ago
We wouldn't know how to construct those matrices because we don't know where in the layers what knowledge is represented. One thing that helps a little bit is freezing the lower layers, so at least the model won't forget its most fundamental knowledge.

Note that the only reason that things are catastrophically forgotten, is that the original examples are not shown again. If the model learns in a single shot, there might simply be no time to show both the old and the new examples. I don't think it would have a significant effect or else we'd know about this effect a lot sooner (i.e. the training of these LLM's would get less effective from a certain point)

link
jacquesm 1010 days ago
You could simulate this by selectively locking and unlocking 'banks' of weights from a larger model to keep the influence there during training and to avoid losing them. Sort of a selective write-protect.
link
samstave 1009 days ago
<"where in the layers what knowledge is represented."

This seems like a ripe angle for evolvement of our understanding of AIs use in LLMs... can we throw AIs at AIs (is AI synonymous to LLM?) Can we throw LLMs at LLMs? and have them recursively learn from themselves.. or is it a Rat King. AI recognize AI in the GangPlane

link
tinco 1009 days ago
That's not how LLM's work. LLM's complete documents, they don't make statements about LLM's unless you explain to them how they should do it and give them all the information they need. If you could extract the information from an LLM well enough to supply that to an LLM with an explanation on how to summarize the behaviour of the LLM to a human, we would have already done that to a PhD student instead. A PhD student is a little bit slower than an LLM, but they require a lot less explanation.

In any case, looking at and understanding how a neural network encodes information is like gene editing. Perhaps you could isolate a gene in the human genome that achieves something interesting like giving a child blue eyes. But even if you would do that, there's a chance you break something else if you modify that gene and give the child health risk. Since all neurons in a deep neural network are interconnected, there is a butterfly effect in it that makes them inherently somewhat of a black box.

link