Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by uuuuuuuuuid 1013 days ago
I imagine someone in the many many comments has already suggested this. But just in case:

It wound be great if all of my emails to security@somewebsite.con could be CC’d to security@fcc.gov and that would immediately convey to me, somewebsite, and the FCC (and anyone else) that I am indeed disclosing and not ransoming.

I understand there would be a cost that the FCC would bear. I just think it would be a worthwhile cost to incur.

2 comments

I like the general idea of improving communication / transparency.

Perhaps some branch of the government could provide a registry for responsible disclosure (e.g., `https://some-branch.gov/responsible-disclosure`). As a security researcher, you could notify the government of your intent to disclose as a demonstration of due diligence and good faith.

The registry/site could return a case/reference number that could be included with the disclosure to the manufacturer. In addition to discouraging an attitude of defensive reprisal, it might also prevail a greater sense of urgency upon the manufacturer to follow through with remediations.

I'm not sure if it'd be necessary/useful but it might also be interesting to leverage zero-knowledge proofs so that interested parties could verify when the contents of a disclosure were made available without actually accessing the contents until after some attempts at remediation.
This seems like a pretty clear breach of first amendment rights (we have a right to choose what we say, and who we say it to). It is probably a good idea for researchers to implement this strategy, and obviously more protections are needed for researchers in this area, but eroding the bill of rights is not the way.
Im a little confused. Can you explain how their proposal is a first ammendment violation? If you're reffering to "could be CC'd to security@fcc.gov," I assume they mean make it an option, not make it mandatory. Some companies attack you for trying to disclose bugs and exploits -- saying that you're attempting to ransom.