Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by scarface_74 1020 days ago
Yes and raise prices on everyone? How do you just “tax Apple” and not everyone else?
1 comments

Based on share of profits for any given market, like smartphones or laptops.
You realize Apple has less than 20% of the PC market? Every company already pays taxes on profits
I said "share of profits". Though perhaps I should have said revenue. Regardless Apple has 85% of smartphone profit. And its share of services on mobile and laptops is growing.
And I fail to see the difference. If Apple has 85% of the profits in cell phones, it’s already paying 85% of the taxes in the cell phone market.
This isn't about the taxes (which they mostly dodge or pass on to consumers). It's about choice. With a chokehold on market revenue they crowd out competitors which reduces consumer choice over time.
Whose fault is it that Amazon, Facebook and Google - all trillion dollar market cap companies are not able to compete? Amazon and Facebook both tried creating their own phone.

Consumers have choice. They can buy from Apple or any number of much cheaper Android devices. They made a choice to pay Apple more. It’s consumers making a choice that led to Apple’s revenue.

Both Google and Microsoft have better services than Apple and they still can’t compete.

Google is worth a trillion dollars plus, have their own operating system and has the most visited page on the internet and still is estimated to sell as many phones in a year that Apple sells in less than a month.

It’s not Apple being anti-competitive. It’s the competitors - all large companies - being incompetent.

In the computer space, Apple was a nobody and almost bankrupt compared to Dell and HP in 1997 when Jobs came back. Why were they so incompetently run?

Why couldn’t Microsoft make a competitive ARM chip?