Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Klonoar 1018 days ago
> but it will become one with tens- or hundreds-of-thousands of refcounted objects which are frequently created and destroyed (and with a naive approach those numbers are easily in reach as soon as table views come into play)

Look, I'm sorry but it's just bananas to throw around "hundreds of thousands of refcounted objects" when I've already bluntly pointed out that I'm discussing general application building. Joe Schmoe wanting to put together an email client should be able to slap a column view somewhere that can render a virtualized list and move on with their life.

This has been fine in multiple different native widget kits for some time now. It is not as intensive as what some games want to do UI-wise. The current situation does lead to overly complex UI approaches and contributes to the general approach of "smack it with a web browser" that we all collectively bemoan.

1 comments

> Joe Schmoe wanting to put together an email client ... and move on with their life.

Tbh, for that type of problem a smart Joe Schmoe wouldn't pick a tech stack like Rust in the first place, and instead just write a simple web app (because implementation details aside, the next problem is how to distribute the damn thing without "sideloading" or "potentially harmful download" warnings popping up all over the place).

You're focusing on the "email" part when the point is the widget type itself, which signals to me we've reached some form of an end to this I guess.

(And that's not even going in to why one might not want to deal with the web)