Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by swyx 1024 days ago
i mean, Midjourney would beg to differ, I think they've done plenty well basing their business on discord.
6 comments

Midjourney's business would be at least 10x what it is today if it wasn't for the utter dogshit Discord integration. I'll continue to give my money to inferior but technically capable companies instead. I don't want to navigate to a fucking chat channel to get my renders.
Last time I checked, they had a website where you can access your generated content. You should just log in with your Discord account.
N of 1 of course, but the moment there's an alternative of sufficient quality I will ditch Midjourney and never look back, for the sole reason that I need to use their service via a Discord bot.
MidJourney is successful despite being on Discord, not because of it.
Ok and what if randomly one day they get banned? They lose 90% of their customers that don't want to move off Discord?
I doubt that Discord is the driver behind their success. They could have used IRC and people would go out of their way to engage with them because what they're doing was so interesting at the time. If they get banned from Discord, the vast majority of the community will move to wherever they go.

This is a different situation than something like app stores where if Apple bans you, that's the end of your company. Users simply cannot get your app from somewhere else, at least not without giving an Android vendor $1000. Nobody will do that.

That might have been true before, but there are viable competitors popping up.
I wish they used irc instead of discord, the UX options available are much better. As it is I can barely use mid journey.
Does https://www.midjourney.com/app/ work better than interacting with Discord chat?
Midjourney has been successful and then what?
it's a huge business risk