Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by remarkEon 1029 days ago
>I don't think it's justice, as it stands.

Can you clarify what you mean here? Do you think the guy who made the joke should go to prison?

2 comments

My reading of the part you quoted is, "It isn't justice because only the charges were dismissed, they owe him more than a simple apology."
Right, but the preceding sentences seem to conflict with that. More over, the following part of the comment

>Stating that the local police are acting unlawfully ... as a prank, is dangerous. You cannot convince me otherwise.

suggests that the guy who made the joke did something dangerous and should be punished for it. At least, that's the implication I'm reading.

I think you're right. The meaning is unclear.
> Do you think the guy who made the joke should go to prison?

I think the legal precedent is damaging. I make no judgement on sentencing, as there was no harm done.

What legal precedent? The existing legal precedent that satire is okay?
To be clear, the precedent the case establishes, expanding the previous slightly.