Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by runn1ng 5207 days ago
You can use bitcoin for any amount you want. And yet, except for the drug sellers on silkroad, almost no one does.

I, personally, see the biggest disadvantage of bitcoin (1) the price unstability - it jumps up and down like crazy, and (2) the still unclear legality - from the tax endpoint, and the like. And (3) - also its biggest strength - it's as safe as your PC is safe. When someone steals your Microsoft Word documents or your Excel tables, who cares. If someone steals your wallet.dat, you are screwed. Period.

It may seem like a moot point, but both Mt.Gox - the largest exchange of bitcoins - and Slush - second largest miner - has had its servers compromised. And those are the highest end-points. Now think of all the users - the lowest end-points, who have "password" as their PC password. You want THEM to have all their money on their wallet.dat files, on their disks?

Now, drug sellers on silkroad really don't care about the second point, but much of the regular businesses do. On the other hands, the regular users have their lowly secured PCs as the only gateway to their money.

I am not sure if Bitcoin will ever get off, given all these circumstances.

1 comments

1) with enough widespread adoption this would be smoothed out, after all the value of the dollar against other currencies is not static either.

2) yup, this is a problem, though I believe technically it should be a capital gain in most countries.

3) This is also clearly a problem though not an unsurmountable one. The cool thing about bitcoin is that you don't have to run the wallet locally, but you have the choice of doing so if you want to. With widespread adoption I believe you would see banks who host wallets, this is how your average person would interact with bitcoin. The final piece of the puzzle is bitcoin insurance to guard against a nefarious wallet hoster, we don't have this yet but there is no reason why it can't be done.