Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by fatfingerd 1035 days ago
Yes, I meant the 5th is only to avoid testimony incriminating himself, which he couldn't do.
1 comments

No, the "right to remain silent" is absolute. It's a refusal to testify to anything at all. The grounds of self-incrimination are there, but if nobody knows what you'll be asked or how you'll answer, those grounds are sort of immaterial.
> No, the "right to remain silent" is absolute.

Constitutionally, no, the right referenced by that phrase in, e.g., the Miranda warnings is the 5th Amendment right against self-incrimination (“No person... shall be compelled in any criminal case to be a witness against himself”).

The belief that a more general “right to remain silent” exists may be a moral belief of some people, but, it is not a legal right, and judges can and will conduct questioning to assess if the legal right applies.

What do you mean if nobody knows what you'll be asked? You have to actually have been asked something to decline to answer.
This is correct.

You can’t just say you are invoking the 5th and refuse to testify. If pressed, you actually have to get up there and invoke it — possibly to every question if needed.

The fear of perjury is an interesting twist, though. And the removal of immunity may affect things too.

(Although in your own trial you have the right to not testify, that doesn’t apply here).

> The fear of perjury is an interesting twist, though.

Its a nice try, but the right not to testify against yourself is not a right not to testify in a situation in which you might be tempted to choose (perjury not being a crime you can connit accidentally) to commit a crime.

What if you're a pathological liar?
Then you can choose psychiatric incarceration?
What about the belief that you can't selectively invoke it? That if you break that silence then they can compel you to answer everything else from that point on? How's that work?

They might as well abolish this right anyway. As if every device we ever touch won't testify against us in the first place.