Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by gumby 1037 days ago
I was told long ago that the water was needed to support the stalks (over the last 20K or so years humans have engineered edible grasses to have absurdly large seeds).

But I guess that isn't the case.

4 comments

Definitely not the case. At least here in Japan, right now the seeds are large, but the fields are mostly not flooded. I believe the reason for flooding the seedlings is to crowd out weeds, which unlike rice are unable to get established.
I guess that's why the article says at the end "The primary barrier to entry for farmers is a 500,000 rupiah ($33) weeding machine."
That’s really sad. A massive productivity boost being missed for a cost that low.
Sounds like a good case for cap n trade, if there's any trust left to be had in that system.
The rice grown in Australia[0] uses a higher water level in colder months to protect against the weather with thermal mass, rather than to physically support the stalks: https://www.agriculturaltoursriverina.com.au/how-is-rice-gro....

Bali has reliably warmer weather than the Riverina in the winter months, so at a guess insulation would be less relevant for Balinese farmers.

[0] Australian rice growing is good for comparison because it necessarily has to be more water efficient and is more heavily industrialised than Indonesia

Not sure where you heard that. Everything I've read (and a quick google search to confirm) indicates that rice fields are flooded because it's a cheap way to prevent weeds and pests from destroying crop yields.
Historically, that may have been an issue. But modern ("Green Revolution") rice varieties are mostly dwarf or semi-dwarf, which plausibly reduces that need.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Semi-dwarf_IR36

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6824242/